Well, I got a call from an official from AFROTC, and despite my attempt to appeal, I was definitely denied.
The second set of SAT scores I sent were taken 3 days after the December 1 deadline. The only December SAT date is December 4th, why does the website say the last possible SAT test is the December test, when they meant "before December 1st?"
Bright side: I can apply for AFROTC almost immediately once I start college, and possibly get a 3-year scholarship.
Dark side: RPI is going to cost me 20,500 for my first year, not even taking into account international flights and everything I need to move into college. Which includes an obligatory laptop.